mardi 11 mars 2008

Why would it be natural to oppose science and religion?

At first sight, religion and science have little in common, of course. One is about faith and the other is about doubts. In their nature, however, they are similar. Both are a quest of truth.

A more realistic statement would be that the purpose of science is to produce useful models of reality [1]. One can of course argue on the exact meaning of words, but this definition is apt to create a consensus. As for religion, being religious can be considered equivalent to believing in the existence of supernatural entities (referred to hereafter as gods) that rule or influence the natural world.

One can only speculate on why people have first come to believe in the existence of gods [2, 3]. It seems to me that gods contribute to make the world more understandable, if not predictable. A catastrophe occurs, say, heavy rains followed by a flood. Attributing this to the anger of some god, rather than to mere chance, is a way to preserve the comfortable idea that everything happens for a reason. Moreover, this explanation is also enticing because it provides people with a means of controlling Nature (do not irritate the gods). Therefore, humans might well have created gods because their world ought to be understandable and controllable; in other words, the inventors of gods believed in causality and in determinism.

From that perspective, gods are simply a mental representation of the principles that control Nature. So to speak, gods are a model of reality. And that early model was definitely useful in helping people accept their faith and keep living, which is sometimes described as an evolutionary asset [2]. According to the definition given above, the creation of gods can be though of as a scientific process. Another obvious usefulness of religions is that they helped people believe in causality and determinism, which beliefs eventually happened to be so fruitful in the development of our technological world during the last three centuries or so.

However complex they may seem, nowadays models - like general relativity, or DNA - are far simpler than the psychology of an irascible god. Simple models are useful only because their domains of applicability are very limited. The laws of physics explain only a very small fraction of the physical world because they are all conditional [4]. No prediction can be made unless the initial state of a system is known, and most human questionings about Nature concern the initial conditions that physics says nothing about. Even more fundamentally, the way physics tries to grasp the notion of time is via evolution laws, which are somehow opposed to the truly creative evolution that is central to anybody’s life [5].

Science accumulated spectacular achievements by restricting its models to more and more limited domains of applicability. The evolution of religions is quite opposite: they evolved towards more and more general principles, such as Good and Evil, which generalization culminates in monotheism. The achievements of religions, and notably of monotheistic religions, are unquestionable given the civilizations they contributed to develop and the way they still shape the human mentalities all over the world. The appeal of their generalizing and unifying ideals to the human nature makes no doubt.

Not so surprisingly is now science moving towards more general models and paradigms than in the past. The hypothetical grand unification theory between nuclear interactions and electromagnetism is just an example. The appeal of multi- or trans-disciplinary researches is also very similar. Trans-disciplinary researches, by attempting to enlarge the initial domains of applicability of models, have already resulted in shaking some of the founding ideas of modern science. Reductionism – which is a basis of the experimental method – is now known to be of limited applicability as some systems are subject to emergence [6].

In summary, the self-confidence of the positivists of the 19th century is not defensible at the beginning of the 21st century. Moderate religion and lucid science are just two different aspects of the same questioning of mankind, torn between the need of simple models for making accurate predictions and the appeal of general principles that would give life a meaning. The endless lines about creationism –just to mention one- that are superficially presented as an opposition between religion and science are merely a clash between fanaticism and intellectual honesty.

[1] This nice definition was in a previous version of the entry about Science in Wikipedia. It seems that the article in question was recently victim of much vandalism.
[2] R. M. Henig, Darwin’s God, New York Times Magazine, March 4 2007.
[3] U. Eco, God isn't big enough for some people,
http://www.umbertoeco.com/id-49/Umberto_Eco_About_God.html.
[4] E. Wigner, The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences, Communications in Pure and Applied Mathematics 13 (1960);
http://www.dartmouth.edu/~matc/MathDrama/reading/Wigner.html
[5] I. Prigogine, From Being To Becoming, Freeman: 1980.
[6] P.W. Anderson, More Is Different, Science 177, (1972) pp. 393-396.

vendredi 7 mars 2008

mardi 26 février 2008

La vache du voisin est malade...

C'est pas grand chose mais ça fait toujours plaisir.
(Sagesse populaire)

jeudi 21 février 2008

Bohmian mechanics and the organized skepticism

A few days ago, I read the paper about Bohmian mechanics on the website of the Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy (SEP) [1]. The last time I came across the name of David Bohm [2] was during my stay in Princeton in 2005. I was subletting a house of Princeton University and people in the neighborhood had the habit of leaving on a shelf at the laundry any book they didn’t want to carry along when they were moving out. In one of these, there was a chapter about scientists in Princeton who had been the victims of McCarthy. David Bohm was one of them.

David Bohm had worked on the Manhattan project, he was assistant professor at Princeton University in 1949. After being suspected of being a communist, he was fired from Princeton and he could not find any position in any other American university. He worked in several countries -notably in Brazil- and he eventually settled in London, where he died in 1992.

The exile of David Bohm was actually twofold: not only was he persona non grata in his own country, he was also left out of the international clique of physicists who mattered. Not surprisingly is Bohmian mechanics unorthodox; it is the work of an outcast.

What I realized with the SEP article is that the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics (QM) is not all there is about QM. David Bohm proposed a causal (deterministic) interpretation of quantum mechanics, the predictions of which are identical with the orthodox QM [3]. Philosophically, however, the two theories are at odds. In Bohmian mechanics the particles have a well defined position and momentum, and the wave function acts as a potential (a so-called pilot wave) that guides the particles. Such an approach was claimed to be impossible, and proved to be so by a famous theorem due to John Steward Bell [4]. Interestingly enough, here is what Bell himself wrote in 1987 about Bohmian mechanics [1]:

But why then had Born not told me of this ‘pilot wave’? If only to point out what was wrong with it? Why did von Neumann not consider it? More extraordinarily, why did people go on producing ‘‘impossibility’’ proofs, after 1952, and as recently as 1978? ... Why is the pilot wave picture ignored in text books? Should it not be taught, not as the only way, but as an antidote to the prevailing complacency? To show us that vagueness, subjectivity, and indeterminism, are not forced on us by experimental facts, but by deliberate theoretical choice?

This is the story of David Bohm and of his unorthodox theory. Yet another sad example of organized skepticism turned de facto into dogmatic denial.


[1] http://www.science.uva.nl/~seop/entries/qm-bohm/
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Bohm
[3] D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 85 (1952) 166-180.
[4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell%27s_Theorem

Triletters

A few days ago was HMB's birthday. Happy birthday, H!

vendredi 8 février 2008

Nicolas Caritat, ci-devant marquis de Condorcet

Il y a une statue de Condorcet sur le quai Conti à Paris, à coté de l'hôtel des monnaies, dont il a été contrôleur général. Je connaissais un peu Condorcet pour avoir lu sa biographie écrite par les Badinter. J'ai lu, il n'y a pas très longtemps sa "Lettre d'un père proscrit à sa fille" (lien ci-dessous).

Mon sentiment après l'avoir lue a été: "Merde alors, le pauvre vieux!" Ce n'est pas que je plaignais particulièrement sa situation quand il a écrit cette lettre, toute précaire qu'elle eut été (il se terrait dans un grenier, d’où il n’est sorti que pour mourir emprisonné quelques jours plus tard). C'est plutôt ce que cette lettre laisse transparaître de la succession de souffrances intimes qu'a été sa vie.

A mes yeux, cette lettre est une énumération en 10 pages de toutes les recettes qu'une personne hypersensible a mises au point tout au long de sa vie pour ne pas souffrir, notamment de ses rapports avec les autres. Et il transmet ces recettes à sa fille comme un savoir très précieux.

En vrac. A propos du travail: "Rien n'est donc plus nécessaire a ton bonheur que de t'assurer des moyens dependans de toi seule pour remplir le vide du tems, écarter l'ennui, calmer les inquiétudes, te distraire d'un sentiment pénible". Ou encore: "On peut n'être pas maître de ne pas écouter son coeur, mais on l'est toujours de ne pas l'exciter; et c'est le seul conseil que la raison puisse donner à la sensibilité" Un autre: "N'attends, n'exige des autres, qu'un peu au-dessous de ce que tu ferais pour eux". Etc., etc., etc.

(http://books.google.com/books?id=cis0AAAAMAAJ&pg=PA603&dq=Avis+d%27un+proscrit+%C3%A0+sa+fille).

dimanche 3 février 2008

Another one about perspective

There is something odd in what I see from my flat. Until this morning, I thought you could get on the roof through that door...